Folding: reporting instantaneous performance metrics and source-code references

Despite supercomputers deliver huge computational power, applications only reach a fraction of it. There are several factors limiting the application performance, and one of the most important is the single processor efficiency because it ultimately dictates the overall achieved performance. We present the folding mechanism, a process that combines measurements captured through minimal instrumentation and coarse-grain sampling ensuring low time dilation (less than 5%). The mechanism reports instantaneous performance and source-code references for optimized binaries accurately by taking advantage of the repetitiveness of many applications, especially in HPC. The mechanism enables the exploration of the application performance and guides the analyst to source-code modifications

Folding: reporting instantaneous performance metrics and source-code references

Despite supercomputers deliver huge computational power, applications only reach a fraction of it. There are several factors limiting the application performance, and one of the most important is the single processor efficiency because it ultimately dictates the overall achieved performance. We present the folding mechanism, a process that combines measurements captured through minimal instrumentation and coarse-grain sampling ensuring low time dilation (less than 5%). The mechanism reports instantaneous performance and source-code references for optimized binaries accurately by taking advantage of the repetitiveness of many applications, especially in HPC. The mechanism enables the exploration of the application performance and guides the analyst to source-code modifications

Bio-inspired call-stack reconstruction for performance analysis

The correlation of performance bottlenecks and their associated source code has become a cornerstone of performance analysis. It allows understanding why the efficiency of an application falls behind the computer's peak performance and enabling optimizations on the code ultimately. To this end, performance analysis tools collect the processor call-stack and then combine this information with measurements to allow the analyst comprehend the application behavior. Some tools modify the call-stack during run-time to diminish the collection expense but at the cost of resulting in non-portable solutions. In this paper, we present a novel portable approach to associate performance issues with their source code counterpart. To address it, we capture a reduced segment of the call-stack (up to three levels) and then process the segments using an algorithm inspired by multi-sequence alignment techniques. The results of our approach are easily mapped to detailed performance views, enabling the analyst to unveil the application behavior and its corresponding region of code. To demonstrate the usefulness of our approach, we have applied the algorithm to several first-time seen in-production applications to describe them finely, and optimize them by using tiny modifications based on the analyses.We thankfully acknowledge Mathis Bode for giving us access to the Arts CF binaries, and Miguel Castrillo and Kim Serradell for their valuable insight regarding Nemo. We would like to thank Forschungszentrum Jülich for the computation time on their Blue Gene/Q system. This research has been partially funded by the CICYT under contracts No. TIN2012-34557 and TIN2015-65316-P.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

Towards instantaneous performance analysis using coarse-grain sampled and instrumented data

Nowadays, supercomputers deliver an enormous amount of computation power; however, it is well-known that applications only reach a fraction of it. One limiting factor is the single processor performance because it ultimately dictates the overall achieved performance. Performance analysis tools help locating performance inefficiencies and their nature to ultimately improve the application performance. Performance tools rely on two collection techniques to invoke their performance monitors: instrumentation and sampling. Instrumentation refers to inject performance monitors into concrete application locations whereas sampling invokes the installed monitors to external events. Each technique has its advantages. The measurements obtained through instrumentation are directly associated to the application structure while sampling allows a simple way to determine the volume of measurements captured. However, the granularity of the measurements that provides valuable insight cannot be determined a priori. Should analysts study the performance of an application for the first time, they may consider using a performance tool and instrument every routine or use high-frequency sampling rates to provide the most detailed results. These approaches frequently lead to large overheads that impact the application performance and thus alter the measurements gathered and, therefore, mislead the analyst. This thesis introduces the folding mechanism that takes advantage of the repetitiveness found in many applications. The mechanism smartly combines metrics captured through coarse-grain sampling and instrumentation mechanisms to provide instantaneous metric reports within instrumented regions and without perturbing the application execution. To produce these reports, the folding processes metrics from different type of sources: performance and energy counters, source code and memory references. The process depends on their nature. While performance and energy counters represent continuous metrics, the source code and memory references refer to discrete values that point out locations within the application code or address space. This thesis evaluates and validates two fitting algorithms used in different areas to report continuous metrics: a Gaussian interpolation process known as Kriging and piece-wise linear regressions. The folding also takes benefit of analytical performance models to focus on a small set of performance metrics instead of exploring a myriad of performance counters. The folding also correlates the metrics with the source-code using two alternatives: using the outcome of the piece-wise linear regressions and a mechanism inspired by Multi-Sequence Alignment techniques. Finally, this thesis explores the applicability of the folding mechanism to captured memory references to detail which and how data objects are accessed. This thesis proposes an analysis methodology for parallel applications that focus on describing the most time-consuming computing regions. It is implemented on top of a framework that relies on a previously existing clustering tool and the folding mechanism. To show the usefulness of the methodology and the framework, this thesis includes the discussion of multiple first-time seen in-production applications. The discussions include high level of detail regarding the application performance bottlenecks and their responsible code. Despite many analyzed applications have been compiled using aggressive compiler optimization flags, the insight obtained from the folding mechanism has turned into small code transformations based on widely-known optimization techniques that have improved the performance in some cases. Additionally, this work also depicts power monitoring capabilities of recent processors and discusses the simultaneous performance and energy behavior on a selection of benchmarks and in-production applications.Actualment, els supercomputadors ofereixen una àmplia potència de càlcul però les aplicacions només en fan servir una petita fracció. Un dels factors limitants és el rendiment d'un processador, el qual dicta el rendiment en general. Les eines d'anàlisi de rendiment ajuden a localitzar els colls d'ampolla i la seva natura per a, eventualment, millorar el rendiment de l'aplicació. Les eines d'anàlisi de rendiment empren dues tècniques de recol·lecció de dades: instrumentació i mostreig. La instrumentació es refereix a la capacitat d'injectar monitors en llocs específics del codi mentre que el mostreig invoca els monitors quan ocórren esdeveniments externs. Cadascuna d'aquestes tècniques té les seves avantatges. Les mesures obtingudes per instrumentació s'associen directament a l'estructura de l'aplicació mentre que les obtingudes per mostreig permeten una forma senzilla de determinar-ne el volum capturat. Sigui com sigui, la granularitat de les mesures no es pot determinar a priori. Conseqüentment, si un analista vol estudiar el rendiment d'una aplicació sense saber-ne res, hauria de considerar emprar una eina d'anàlisi i instrumentar cadascuna de les rutines o bé emprar freqüències de mostreig altes per a proveir resultats detallats. En qualsevol cas, aquestes alternatives impacten en el rendiment de l'aplicació i per tant alterar les mètriques capturades, i conseqüentment, confondre a l'analista. Aquesta tesi introdueix el mecanisme anomenat folding, el qual aprofita la repetitibilitat existent en moltes aplicacions. El mecanisme combina intel·ligentment mètriques obtingudes mitjançant mostreig de gra gruixut i instrumentació per a proveir informes de mètriques instantànies dins de regions instrumentades sense pertorbar-ne l'execució. Per a produir aquests informes, el mecanisme processa les mètriques de diferents fonts: comptadors de rendiment i energia, codi font i referències de memoria. El procés depen de la natura de les dades. Mentre que les mètriques de rendiment i energia són valors continus, el codi font i les referències de memòria representen valors discrets que apunten ubicacions dins el codi font o l'espai d'adreces. Aquesta tesi evalua i valida dos algorismes d'ajust: un procés d'interpolació anomenat Kriging i una interpolació basada en regressions lineals segmentades. El mecanisme de folding també s'aprofita de models analítics de rendiment basats en comptadors hardware per a proveir un conjunt reduït de mètriques enlloc d'haver d'explorar una multitud de comptadors. El mecanisme també correlaciona les mètriques amb el codi font emprant dues alternatives: per un costat s'aprofita dels resultats obtinguts per les regressions lineals segmentades i per l'altre defineix un mecanisme basat en tècniques d'alineament de multiples seqüències. Aquesta tesi també explora l'aplicabilitat del mecanisme per a referències de memoria per a informar quines i com s'accessedeixen les dades de l'aplicació. Aquesta tesi proposa una metodología d'anàlisi per a aplicacions paral·leles centrant-se en descriure les regions de càlcul que consumeixen més temps. La metodología s'implementa en un entorn de treball que usa un mecanisme de clustering preexistent i el mecanisme de folding. Per a demostrar-ne la seva utilitat, aquesta tesi inclou la discussió de múltiples aplicacions analitzades per primera vegada. Les discussions inclouen un alt nivel de detall en referencia als colls d'ampolla de les aplicacions i de la seva natura. Tot i que moltes d'aquestes aplicacions s'han compilat amb opcions d'optimització agressives, la informació obtinguda per l'entorn de treball es tradueix en petites modificacions basades en tècniques d'optimització que permeten millorar-ne el rendiment en alguns casos. Addicionalment, aquesta tesi també reporta informació sobre el consum energètic reportat per processadors recents i discuteix el comportament simultani d'energia i rendiment en una selecció d'aplicacions sintètiques i aplicacions en producció

Automating the application data placement in hybrid memory systems

Multi-tiered memory systems, such as those based on Intel® Xeon Phi™processors, are equipped with several memory tiers with different characteristics including, among others, capacity, access latency, bandwidth, energy consumption, and volatility. The proper distribution of the application data objects into the available memory layers is key to shorten the time– to–solution, but the way developers and end-users determine the most appropriate memory tier to place the application data objects has not been properly addressed to date.In this paper we present a novel methodology to build an extensible framework to automatically identify and place the application’s most relevant memory objects into the Intel Xeon Phi fast on-package memory. Our proposal works on top of inproduction binaries by first exploring the application behavior and then substituting the dynamic memory allocations. This makes this proposal valuable even for end-users who do not have the possibility of modifying the application source code. We demonstrate the value of a framework based in our methodology for several relevant HPC applications using different allocation strategies to help end-users improve performance with minimal intervention. The results of our evaluation reveal that our proposal is able to identify the key objects to be promoted into fast on-package memory in order to optimize performance, leading to even surpassing hardware-based solutions.This work has been performed in the Intel-BSC Exascale Lab. Antonio J. Peña is cofinanced by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness under Juan de la Cierva fellowship number IJCI-2015-23266. We would like to thank the Intel’s DCG HEAT team for allowing us to access their computational resources. We also want to acknowledge this team, especially Larry Meadows and Jason Sewall, as well as Pardo Keppel for the productive discussions. We thank Raphaël Léger for allowing us to access the MAXW-DGTD application and its input.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

MetH: A family of high-resolution and variable-shape image challenges

High-resolution and variable-shape images have not yet been properly addressed by the AI community. The approach of down-sampling data often used with convolutional neural networks is sub-optimal for many tasks, and has too many drawbacks to be considered a sustainable alternative. In sight of the increasing importance of problems that can benefit from exploiting high-resolution (HR) and variable-shape, and with the goal of promoting research in that direction, we introduce a new family of datasets (MetH). The four proposed problems include two image classification, one image regression and one super resolution task. Each of these datasets contains thousands of art pieces captured by HR and variable-shape images, labeled by experts at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. We perform an analysis, which shows how the proposed tasks go well beyond current public alternatives in both pixel size and aspect ratio variance. At the same time, the performance obtained by popular architectures on these tasks shows that there is ample room for improvement. To wrap up the relevance of the contribution we review the fields, both in AI and high-performance computing, that could benefit from the proposed challenges.This work is partially supported by the Intel-BSC Exascale Lab agreement, by the Spanish Government through Programa Severo Ochoa (SEV-2015-0493), by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Technology through TIN2015-65316-P project, and by the Generalitat de Catalunya (contracts 2017-SGR-1414).Preprin

Integrating memory perspective into the BSC performance tools

The growing gap between processor and memory speeds results in complex memory hierarchies as processors evolve to mitigate such differences by taking advantage of locality of reference. In this direction, the BSC performance analysis tools have been recently extended to provide insight relative the application memory accesses depicting their temporal and spatial characteristics, correlating with the source-code and the achieved performance simultaneously. These extensions rely on the Precise Event-Based Sampling (PEBS) mechanism available in recent Intel processors to capture information relative to the application memory accesses. The sampled information is processed with the Folding mechanism to provide a detailed temporal evolution of the memory accesses and in conjunction with the achieved performance and the source-code counterpart. The results obtained from the combination of these tools help application developers to understand better how the application behaves and how the system performs. We demonstrate the value of the complete work-flow by exploring an already optimized state-of-the-art benchmark, providing detailed insight of their memory access behavior.This work has been performed in the Intel-BSC Exascale Lab. We would like to thank Forschungszentrum Julich for the compute time on the Jureca system. Antonio J. Peña is cofinanced by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness under Juan de la Cierva fellowship number IJCI-2015-23266.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

Runtime-guided management of stacked DRAM memories in task parallel programs

Stacked DRAM memories have become a reality in High-Performance Computing (HPC) architectures. These memories provide much higher bandwidth while consuming less power than traditional off-chip memories, but their limited memory capacity is insufficient for modern HPC systems. For this reason, both stacked DRAM and off-chip memories are expected to co-exist in HPC architectures, giving raise to different approaches for architecting the stacked DRAM in the system. This paper proposes a runtime approach to transparently manage stacked DRAM memories in task-based programming models. In this approach the runtime system is in charge of copying the data accessed by the tasks to the stacked DRAM, without any complex hardware support nor modifications to the application code. To mitigate the cost of copying data between the stacked DRAM and the off-chip memory, the proposal includes an optimization to parallelize the copies across idle or additional helper threads. In addition, the runtime system is aware of the reuse pattern of the data accessed by the tasks, and can exploit this information to avoid unworthy copies of data to the stacked DRAM. Results on the Intel Knights Landing processor show that the proposed techniques achieve an average speedup of 14% against the state-of-the-art library to manage the stacked DRAM and 29% against a stacked DRAM architected as a hardware cache.This work has been supported by the RoMoL ERC Advanced Grant (GA 321253), by the European HiPEAC Network of Excellence, by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (contract TIN2015-65316-P), by the Generalitat de Catalunya (contracts 2014-SGR-1051 and 2014-SGR-1272) and by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (grant agreement 779877). M. Moreto has been partially supported by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness under Ramon y Cajal fellowship number RYC-2016-21104.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

The Mont-Blanc prototype: an alternative approach for high-performance computing systems

High-performance computing (HPC) is recognized as one of the pillars for further advance of science, industry, medicine, and education. Current HPC systems are being developed to overcome emerging challenges in order to reach Exascale level of performance,which is expected by the year 2020. The much larger embedded and mobile market allows for rapid development of IP blocks, and provides more flexibility in designing an application-specific SoC, in turn giving possibility in balancing performance, energy-efficiency and cost. In the Mont-Blanc project, we advocate for HPC systems be built from such commodity IP blocks, currently used in embedded and mobile SoCs. As a first demonstrator of such approach, we present the Mont-Blanc prototype; the first HPC system built with commodity SoCs, memories, and NICs from the embedded and mobile domain, and off-the-shelf HPC networking, storage, cooling and integration solutions. We present the system’s architecture, and evaluation including both performance and energy efficiency. Further, we compare the system’s abilities against a production level supercomputer. At the end, we discuss parallel scalability, and estimate the maximum scalability point of this approach across a set of HPC applications.Postprint (published version